Effect of partner responsiveness in aphasia discourse (Harmon et al., 2019)
journal contributionposted on 2019-12-18, 22:51 authored by Tyson G. Harmon, Adam Jacks, Katarina L. Haley, Antoine Bailliard
Purpose: Because people with aphasia (PWA) frequently interact with partners who are unresponsive to their communicative attempts, we investigated how partner responsiveness affects quantitative measures of spoken language and subjective reactions during story retell.
Method: A quantitative study and a qualitative study were conducted. In Study 1, participants with aphasia and controls retold short stories to a communication partner who indicated interest through supportive backchannel responses (responsive) and another who indicated disinterest through unsupportive backchannel responses (unresponsive). Story retell accuracy, delivery speed, and ratings of psychological stress were measured and compared. In Study 2, participants completed semistructured interviews about their story retell experience, which were recorded, transcribed, and coded using qualitative analysis software.
Results: Quantitative results revealed increased psychological stress and decreased delivery speed across all participant groups during the unresponsive partner condition. Effects on delivery speed were more consistent for controls than participants with aphasia. Qualitative results revealed that participants with aphasia were more attuned to unresponsive partner behaviors than controls and reported stronger and more frequent emotional reactions. Partner responsiveness also affected how PWA perceived and coped with the communication experience.
Conclusions: Combined quantitative and qualitative findings suggest that, while unresponsive communication partners may not have robust effects on spoken language, they elicit strong emotional reactions from PWA and affect their communication experience. These findings support the need for communication partner training and suggest that training PWA on emotion regulation or relaxation techniques may help assuage their anxiety during socially challenging everyday communication and increase social participation.
Supplemental Material S1. Responsive partner condition video example.
Supplemental Material S2. Unresponsive partner condition video example.
Supplemental Material S3. Correlations between apprehension ratings and psychological stress, story retell accuracy, and story retell speed.
Supplemental Material S4. Interview guide.
Harmon, T. G., Jacks, A., Haley, K. L., & Bailliard, A. (2019). How responsiveness from a communication partner affects story retell in aphasia: Quantitative and qualitative findings. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1044/2019_AJSLP-19-0091
This work was supported by a Dissertation Completion Fellowship Award from the University of North Carolina Graduate School.
Read the peer-reviewed publication
communicationspeechaphasiaspeech-language pathologyresponsivepartnerstoryretellPWAattemptspokenreactionshort storyinterestsupportivedisinterestunresponsiveaccuracyspeedpsychologicalstressinterviewrecordedtranscribedcodedcontrolsemotionresponsivenessperceptioncopingexperiencetrainingregulationrelaxationsocialparticipationquality of lifelonelinessisolationinteractionLinguistic Processes (incl. Speech Production and Comprehension)Communication Studies