ASHA journals
2 files

Agrammatic Aphasia and Healthy Speakers (Lee et al., 2015)

posted on 2015-08-01, 00:00 authored by Jiyeon Lee, Masaya Yoshida, Cynthia K. Thompson
Purpose Grammatical encoding (GE) is impaired in agrammatic aphasia; however, the nature of such deficits remains unclear. We examined grammatical planning units during real-time sentence production in speakers with agrammatic aphasia and control speakers, testing two competing models of GE. We queried whether speakers with agrammatic aphasia produce sentences word by word without advanced planning or whether hierarchical syntactic structure (i.e., verb argument structure; VAS) is encoded as part of the advanced planning unit.
Method Experiment 1 examined production of sentences with a predefined structure (i.e., "The A and the B are above the C") using eye tracking. Experiment 2 tested production of transitive and unaccusative sentences without a predefined sentence structure in a verb-priming study.
Results In Experiment 1, both speakers with agrammatic aphasia and young and age-matched control speakers used word-by-word strategies, selecting the first lemma (noun A) only prior to speech onset. However, in Experiment 2, unlike controls, speakers with agrammatic aphasia preplanned transitive and unaccusative sentences, encoding VAS before speech onset.
Conclusions Speakers with agrammatic aphasia show incremental, word-by-word production for structurally simple sentences, requiring retrieval of multiple noun lemmas. However, when sentences involve functional (thematic to grammatical) structure building, advanced planning strategies (i.e., VAS encoding) are used. This early use of hierarchical syntactic information may provide a scaffold for impaired GE in agrammatism.


This study was supported by School of Communication Graduate Research Ignition Grant from Northwestern University (J. Lee), NIH R01-DC01948 (C. K. Thompson), and NSF BCS-1323245 (M. Yoshida). The authors thank the individuals with aphasia for their participation.


Usage metrics

    Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research



    Ref. manager