Functional parcellation of speech cortex (Tourville et al., 2019)
figureposted on 2019-08-29, 21:01 authored by Jason A. Tourville, Alfonso Nieto-Castañón, Matthias Heyne, Frank H. Guenther
Neuroimaging has revealed a core network of cortical regions that contribute to speech production, but the functional organization of this network remains poorly understood.
Purpose: We describe efforts to identify reliable boundaries around functionally homogenous regions within the cortical speech motor control network in order to improve the sensitivity of functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) analyses of speech production and thus improve our understanding of the functional organization of speech production in the brain.
Method: We used a bottom-up, data-driven approach by pooling data from 12 previously conducted fMRI studies of speech production involving the production of monosyllabic and bisyllabic words and pseudowords that ranged from single vowels and consonant–vowel pairs to short sentences (163 scanning sessions, 136 unique participants, 39 different speech conditions). After preprocessing all data through the same pipeline and registering individual contrast maps to a common surface space, hierarchical clustering was applied to contrast maps randomly sampled from the pooled data set in order to identify consistent functional boundaries across subjects and tasks. Boundary completion was achieved by applying adaptive smoothing and watershed segmentation to the thresholded population-level boundary map. Hierarchical clustering was applied to the mean within–functional region of interest (fROI) response to identify networks of fROIs that respond similarly during speech.
Results: We identified highly reliable functional boundaries across the cortical areas involved in speech production. Boundary completion resulted in 117 fROIs in the left hemisphere and 109 in the right hemisphere. Clustering of the mean within-fROI response revealed a core sensorimotor network flanked by a speech motor planning network. The majority of the left inferior frontal gyrus clustered with the visual word form area and brain regions (e.g., anterior insula, dorsal anterior cingulate) associated with detecting salient sensory inputs and choosing the appropriate action.
Conclusion: The fROIs provide insight into the organization of the speech production network and a valuable tool for studying speech production in the brain by improving within-group and between-groups comparisons of speech-related brain activity.
Supplemental Material S1. Full labeled map of the cortical speech fROIs overlaid on the FreeSurfer fsaverage inflated cortical surface, including views of the lateral, medial, superior, inferior, anterior, and posterior surfaces of both hemispheres.
Supplemental Material S2. Dendogram of fROIs that resulted from the post-hoc hierarchical clustering of the mean response patterns of all fROIs shown in Supplemental Material S1. Warm colors (red, orange to turquoise) are assigned to fROIs that are more active during speech production than baseline; cool colors are assigned to fROIs that were less active during speech production. Clusters of fROIs that form the networks described in the main article are highlighted and the networks are labeled accordingly.
Tourville, J. A., Nieto-Castañón, A., Heyne, M., Guenther, F. H. (2019). Functional parcellation of the speech production cortex. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 62, 3055-3070. https://doi.org/10.1044/2019_JSLHR-S-CSMC7-18-0442
Publisher Note: This article is part of the Special Issue: Select Papers From the 7th International Conference on Speech Motor Control.
This research was supported by grants from the National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders: R01 DC007683 and DC002852 AQ7 (principal investigator: F. G.).
speechcortexbrainproductionfunctionalparcellationneuroimagingnetworkcorticalregionsorganizationidentifyboundarieshomogenousmotorcontrolsensitivityfMRIbottom-updata-drivenmonosyllablebisyllablewordspseudowordsvowelsconsonantspairscontrastmapssurfacespaceclusteringhierarchicalconsistencyboundaryadaptivesmoothingwatershedregion of interestleft hemispheresensorimotorinferior frontal gyrusvisualanterior insuladorsal anterior cingulatesensoryinputactionactivityAnatomyNeuroscience